This is a thought that I have had that is relatively complex and explains, in my opinion, one of the more difficult topics of suffering, sin, choice and love. This is an interesting topic because it's modeled in God's relationship with man, man's relationship with God and ideally it is to be modeled, in my opinion, reciprocally within marriage. Some will disagree with me but i think it makes perfect sense...but then again I am far from normal.
So I have done a lot of thinking and talking about why life is unfair, how God can allow bad things to happen, how a spouse can cheat on another while saying they still love you. I think I have come to a satisfactory explanation for myself.
Lets start by arguing that love is a choice. Some believe that it is a feeling or an emotion but I disagree. I didn't used too because you do have "feelings" for someone when you are "in love". Is that truly love? I tend to say no, that is infatuation. Having been in the "relationship" that I have been in for the past 10 years I have determined it has to be a choice. I have to choose to forgive. Love doesn't just over-ride the trespasses I've been dealt. Forgiveness is an expression of love. We know this because of John 3:16. I need not quote it. The entire reason God sent Jesus was because he loved us so much, he had to make a way for us to be forgiven. When you have chosen to love someone you have to forgive them for as long as love is your choice. Sometimes the trespasses are too great or the other person in the relationship decides that they are done and want out (does not choose love? is not equally yoked? does not understand true love? incapable of love?). So if you agree with me that love is a choice keep reading, if you disagree go google it and come back once we're on the same page.
So if love is a choice, love cannot exist without choice. Choice is the picking between two options. Often times in life there are what I call "righter" and "wronger" choices. Not all choices are right or wrong, but some are more in accordance with what God wants and others are less so. I won't get into the righter and wronger choice of life though that's another discussion, all I want to note about them is that not all choices are between right and wrong but rather choices based on our perception of right and wrong. Think of full of crap yet? Read Romans 14:23 "But whoever has doubts is condemned if they eat, because their eating is not from faith; and everything that does not come from faith is sin." So some sins are spelled out for us in the Bible, others are more of gray areas of conscience for us. If it's a violation of what you feel is right then you're in the wrong, if it's a choice between two things that can be perceived as right, you have to do the one that more closely aligns with your perception of our freedoms in Christ. So I got a little side tracked in there, but all is important to the grand scheme of things in my opinion. So love is a choice, which means you are choosing between two things. For a person to make a choice they have to have free-will. Without free will, you're just a programmed robot to do right. So free-will is necessary to the existence of love, because love is a choice.
Free-will is really the crux of love. Without it we don't have love, with it we can also have hurt and pain. This is where pain/suffering/injustice come into play. It's hard to believe how closely related all these really big topics are and now that I feel I have come to a marginal understanding of them it makes so much more sense. So PSI (pain, suffering, and injustice) occurs when we make choices outside of God's will. Sometimes these are conscience choices sometimes they are not. Sometimes it's evident the choices we have made, other times people don't know why we suffer what we do. Additionally everyone is impacted by the decisions of others (be it good or bad). So the only way for there to NOT be pain and suffering is for you to perfectly obey God's plan and for those around you to perfectly obey God's plan. What's the odds of that happening? Yeah not to freakin good huh? I know I got plenty to worry about with myself, I don't have time to try to fix other peoples spiritual quandaries. So the only way we can have a world that doesn't have PSI is to have a world without choice and therefore no love. The only way we can have a world with love is to have PSI. Which is greater love or pain and suffering? Love of course. Why do I say that? Do you think Jesus on the cross endured pain and suffering and injustice? Heck yeah he did. Why did he endure it? For love. The only thing worth PSI is love. That means in all relationships there will be some level of PSI because we have free choice such that Love may be present.
Furthermore, free-will is why things in life suck. It's the free-will of ourselves making poor choices and the free-will of those that impact our lives making poor choices that we end up at "this sucks". The fact remains, however, that if this DIDN'T "suck" then we would have nothing to look forward too or work for. For example, if I want to buy a house, I get a job, work hard buy a house and then I have it. What if I were given the house? Then I wouldn't have to get a job then work and save, I would already have the end result. I would not have the fortitude or character or appreciate the house because it was not something that I worked for. This is kinda like our path to Heaven. Our lives here on earth are what I consider to be "Heaven training" if we can get it right(enough) here on earth to live a good life and follow God's will rather than our own then we can get it right in heaven where things will be perfect. The fact is this: some people can be unhappy with perfection. No freakin joke. Even when things are all as they should be, some people will still complain, refusing to do the right thing, it's their nature. We need to make our nature, such that we can live in this broken world and find peace. It's hard to do, but that's because this world is not of peace. Conversely our peace is not of this world. Which means for us to find peace our spirit has to transcend that which we see and put our faith in the unseen God and Jesus Christ. If we can put our faith and hope in them, and remotely understand their sacrifice and Love then we can have peace. Sure you'll still have rough days even when you do understand all that, but you will know where to find your peace in life (and it's not here on earth).
One last thing about free will: I would argue that man is by nature, not good. Some of you may disagree, but I think it only makes sense. Adam and Eve ate of the fruit of knowledge of good and evil. Cain killed Able. These things occurred without any precedence. They invented these wrongs so to speak. If it were our nature to do good, then it wouldn't be so hard to be good. It would be natural to us and doing that which is wrong would be foreign. However, as I know well, it's not always easy for me to do that which I know is right. Some things come easier to me and other things may come easier to you. But ultimately I would argue, we as humans, are evil by nature and good by God. It is for this reason, that when combined free-will and evil nature we get such a corrupt world that causes us the level of pain/suffering/injustice that we experience today.
So lets recap so far before we move on. 1) Love is a choice 2) choice cannot exist without free-will 3) perfection and free-will cannot coexist causing pain/suffering/injustice 4) we are evil by nature. Now let's talk a little more about love. Because this is really where I think I have a different idea.
Love is talked about all the time by people, but what is love? Based on the aforementioned principles and evidences I see in the Bible, I believe that Love is when you choose to do right over wrong because you care more for someone else than you do yourself. First I have to utilize my free-will to choose to love someone. Then I over-ride my natural evil desires. I freely CHOOSE to act in a why that honors that person above myself, my desires and others. THIS is what love is. This is what God wants from us and this is how we should love others. Since we are by nature evil, almost every minute that we choose too honor that person/being we are in effect loving them. So for example someone may have the propensity towards substance abuse. In every moment they choose sobriety they are loving God. It's in that one moment they fail and shoot up or pop the pills that they have given into their evil desires. It's not that they do not love God, it's just that in that moment they did not love Him as much or like they should. They loved their evil desires more. So maybe 1 out of 100 times they fall short but 99 out of 100 they do what they aught. Would you say that because they shot up that they didn't love God? No, that's crazy, 99 times they did right.
This is the same way with our earthly relationships. Too often we are caught up in "ohh he/she did ______ they don't love me" but that's often not the case. What is the case is that they just had a weak moment, but every other moment up til then they chose love and acted accordingly. So say for example my wife cheated on me. It's not that she doesn't love me, it's that in that moment she loved herself more than she loved me. And this is why it is hurtful when something like this happens. You KNOW they love you, their actions typically are in alignment with that notion. However, in a weak or selfish moment they give in to their evil desire. And you know in that moment they loved themselves more than the love you. It's easy to get hung up on those moments in time because they are so hurtful, but we need to focus on the other 99 times that they choose us over themselves. Why? Because that's how God see's us. We cheat on him way more often than one out of a hundred, or at least I know I do. Despite that he keeps taking us back and forgiving us. It is of my opinion that it is when we are faced with decisions and more often choose the wrong that we are in danger in both our relationship with God and with humans. Honestly it is probably less often than choosing wrong half the time that we get into danger. Would you be friends with someone that wronged you half the time? Ha! I know I wouldn't! When you start to see selfish trends like choosing their own desires over loving you, that you know they don't truly love you, they have chosen to love themselves and "love" you when it meets THEIR needs. This is why relationships can be so confusing. How many times have I heard "but he loves me!!" HECK NOT HE DOESN'T!!! He just uses you when it fits HIS desires/will. And it can be any sort of things, not just sexually.
How do we know love? Well 1 Corinthians 13:4-8 describes it to us:
"4 Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. 5 It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. 6 Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. 7 It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres. 8 Love never fails."
This is how we know love. It is when someone is patient with you and kind towards you. It's when they are happy when something good happens for you and not jealous. It's when someone is humble towards you and not rude. They don't look out for their own benefit, but for yours. It's when they don't get mad over every little thing and they don't remember the times you might have had a weak moment. They aren't happy when bad things happen, they always protect you, trust you, hope in you and even when things are hard they push on with you. They never let you down. That's Love right there. Been a while since I felt that. It's a choice you have to make every day. If it's a choice, you can also unchoose it, both spiritually and carnally. So every day you wake up, choose to love. Choose to do right. Choose to serve God and those that you love here on earth.
If we have to live in a world of pain, suffering and injustice so that love can exist, we should take full advantage of every moment we have to love. To love both God and to love people. God felt that Love was worth the pain of free-will, therefore, true love must be worth more than all the suffering we experience in the world. So love and love with all your might.
Eligere Amorem!!